Trading Intelligence vs. Gamification: A New Standard for Investment Platforms

The FCA's Consumer Duty and guidance on Digital Engagement Practices have made it clear: the era of confetti animations, interaction streaks, and gamified nudges designed to maximise trading volume is over. Platforms must now demonstrate they're delivering good outcomes, not just engagement. 

Most investment platforms I speak with understand this. The rules aren't the problem. Implementation is. 

The Implementation Challenge 

Here's what the policy documents don't tell you: knowing what to do is the easy part. Actually doing it is a different matter entirely. 

Platforms are battling legacy technology stacks built over decades, fragmented data sitting in silos that don't communicate, and the uncomfortable reality that compliance has shifted from 'have a policy' to 'prove it works'. Regulators now want evidence of good outcomes, not just documentation of good intentions. 

You cannot demonstrate that your tools lead to better customer outcomes if your data is scattered across disconnected systems. You cannot show explainable reasoning if your analytics are a black box. You cannot evidence compliance if you lack the infrastructure to trace how decisions are made. 

This isn't a front-end problem you can fix with better UX. It's an infrastructure problem: the data, the analytics, and the workflows that tie them together. Until platforms solve for that, everything else is window dressing. 

The solution isn't to stop engaging users. It's to upgrade the quality of that engagement. It's time to move from gamified apps to Trading Intelligence. 

What Trading Intelligence Looks Like 

Trading Intelligence is the opposite of gamification. Where gamification uses design tricks to drive activity, Trading Intelligence uses data, advanced analytics, and intuitive workflows to drive understanding. It's the combination of these three elements that creates genuine value. 

At Engine AI, we built Trading Intelligence to give retail investors access to the same depth of insight that professionals have always enjoyed. Here's what that looks like in practice. 

1. Institutional-Grade Data 

To meet the Consumer Duty's requirement to avoid foreseeable harm, platforms must ensure users aren't trading on rumours, social media hype, or price signals alone. This means giving them access to the same data that institutions use. 

Trading Intelligence integrates data from partners such as S&P Global for fundamental analysis, RavenPack for news sentiment and EPFR for Fund & ETF flows. It covers 3,000+ Equities, 2,000+ ETFs, Crypto, and Global FX Markets in one unified view. By bringing this institutional data together in a single source of truth, users no longer need to piece together information from multiple unverified sources. When they act, they act on evidence. 

2. Advanced Analytics 

Data without context is noise. A user looking at a P/E ratio or moving average might not understand what it signals. Trading Intelligence solves this through a combination of quantitative models, AI, and data engineering that synthesise raw data into actionable insights. 

All data, no, matter how complex, is normalised into an intuitive scale, allowing users to quickly sift through the noise to identify outliers and information that is relevant for their portfolio.  

Think of it as a personal analyst for the DIY investor. Instead of presenting raw numbers, we break down each security across four pillars:  

1. Fundamentals (is the business sound?) 

2. Technicals (what is the price action saying?) 

3. Flows (where is the institutional money going?) 

4. Sentiment (how is the market feeling?)

By delivering consolidated analytics across these factors, platforms can offer outlooks rather than spreadsheets, directly supporting the FCA's cross-cutting rule to enable customers to pursue their financial objectives. 

3. Intuitive, Transparent Workflows  

Perhaps the biggest risk in the age of AI is the 'black box' problem. If a platform highlights a stock without explaining why, it creates dependency, not education. 

This is where workflows matter. Trading Intelligence is built on what we call transparent AI: the ability to show users an answer quickly, with full visibility on the drivers behind it. Within two clicks, a user can move from a high-level outlook to the raw data feeding it.  

If a stock is flagged as an opportunity, users see exactly why: perhaps institutional flows have spiked, or news sentiment has shifted. All sources are cited and traceable. 

A natural language AI assistant allows users to interrogate the data directly. A user can ask 'Why is sentiment negative?' and receive a clear, cited answer. Every interaction becomes a learning moment, satisfying the Consumer Understanding outcome far better than any static risk warning. 

It's this combination of comprehensive data, advanced analytics, and intuitive workflows that creates genuine understanding. Users don't just see superficial price trends; they understand the depth behind the assets they want to trade. 

Turn Regulatory Pressure Into a Competitive Edge  

The platforms that move fastest on this issue will define the next decade of retail investing. Consumer Duty compliance doesn’t have to be a cost centre; it can be a differentiator. 

The good news is that platforms don't need to build this infrastructure from scratch. Trading Intelligence comes pre-loaded with institutional-grade data across multiple asset classes, ready to integrate. What might otherwise take years of data engineering and compliance work can be deployed in weeks. 

When users can trust that your platform helps them make informed decisions rather than just more decisions, they stay longer, trade more confidently, and become advocates. The firms that put too many eggs in the gamification basket will find themselves explaining to regulators why their users exhibit problematic behaviours. The firms building Trading Intelligence will be showing evidence of genuine outcomes. 

I know which conversation I'd rather be having. 

________________________________________________

To explore how Trading Intelligence could work for your platform, book a conversation with the Engine AI team.